
The new junk food advertising ban recognises marketing as a driver of harm. Environmental policy has yet to catch up.
Something quietly radical happened in the UK last month. With little fanfare, the government effectively declared that advertising is not neutral. By banning junk food adverts on TV before 9pm and online altogether, policymakers acknowledged a simple but uncomfortable truth: marketing shapes what we want and ultimately what we buy. When the harm is clear, advertising itself becomes part of the problem.
That insight is not novel in public health but it has barely begun to register in environmental policy. This matters because many of the biggest drivers of biodiversity loss and climate breakdown are not just products on shelves bought by me or you. They are stories told at scale. And those stories are still playing everywhere all the time.
Advertising works
The justification for the junk food ban rests on evidence that has accumulated for decades. Children exposed to repeated advertising for foods high in fat, salt and sugar are more likely to want them, ask for them and eat them. Over time, this contributes to obesity, poor health and rising public costs through the national healthcare system.
Advertising restrictions do not solve the problem on their own. But they reduce exposure, and make it easier to shift norms and ultimately dampen demand. That is why comprehensive tobacco advertising bans are now seen as highly effective public health measures. Countries that closed off all major marketing channels did not just encourage quitting; they saw far fewer people start smoking and overall use decline.
The same pattern is now emerging for junk food. Where advertising restrictions are strong and enforced, children see fewer unhealthy food ads and households buy less of the worst products. Effects are modest in the short term, but meaningful at scale and over time. Crucially, these policies work not because they inform consumers, but because they change the environment in which choices are made.
Selling destruction
Fast fashion is marketed as freedom and self-expression. High-impact foods are wrapped in images of happiness, tradition and convenience. Single-use plastics are framed as hygienic and modern. Fossil fuel companies sponsor sporting events and children’s education programmes while presenting themselves as part of the climate solution.
None of this is accidental. Advertising does not simply respond to demand. It creates it. It normalises overconsumption and pushes environmental costs out of sight and mind. It teaches us what a “normal” lifestyle looks like long before we ever reflect on its consequences.
And it works. People do not overconsume because they are ignorant or immoral. They do so because they live in information environments engineered to make harmful choices feel easy and desirable.
Environmental policy, however, tends to act as if these environments do not exist. We regulate emissions after products are sold. We ask consumers to make better choices while surrounding them with messages urging the opposite. We treat advertising as background noise rather than a powerful behavioural force. The junk food ban exposes how incoherent that approach has become.
The brand loophole
The new rules are not perfect. Big brands can still advertise logos and lifestyles, while smaller companies that rely on product-level messaging are squeezed out. Campaigners rightly warn that this could blunt the policy’s impact.
But this weakness is instructive rather than fatal. Similar loopholes existed in tobacco regulation for years. They were gradually closed as evidence accumulated and public attitudes shifted. What once seemed like radical interference is now taken for granted.
The lesson is not that advertising bans fail. It is that partial measures invite circumvention. Comprehensive ones change norms. Environmental advertising faces the same challenge. If restrictions are timid or inconsistent, companies will adapt. If they are serious, the culture shifts.
The nanny state
Critics inevitably frame advertising regulation as an attack on freedom. The “nanny state” argument resurfaces every time. But banning junk food ads does not ban junk food. It limits how aggressively harmful products can be pushed, especially at children. It recognises that freedom of choice means little when preferences are being engineered from birth.
Applying similar thinking to environmental harm does not require moralising consumers or banning everyday products overnight. It requires asking more basic questions. Should products that drive deforestation be marketed to children as harmless fun? Should fossil fuel companies still buy credibility through advertising while expanding extraction?
These are not extreme questions. They are overdue ones.
Evidence base
Public health has an advantage environmental policy lacks: time. Tobacco advertising bans were introduced decades ago. Their effects have been studied, debated and refined. Environmental advertising bans are only just beginning. France has enacted one of the first national restrictions on advertising fossil fuel energy products, and several cities — including The Hague and Amsterdam — have moved to ban fossil fuel, airline and high-emission vehicle ads in public spaces.
It is too early for long-term evaluations. But the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It reflects political caution, not conceptual weakness. We already know advertising shapes consumption. We already know overconsumption drives environmental harm. What we lack is the willingness to test advertising regulation as part of the solution, rather than treating it as untouchable.
There are also hints of what might follow. In sectors where advertising has been restricted, companies often innovate around less harmful alternatives. When alcohol advertising was banned in Norway, producers invested more heavily in low- and no-alcohol products. When junk food marketing is constrained, manufacturers reformulate. Advertising bans do not just reduce demand. They reshape incentives for both consumers and suppliers.
A moment to notice
The junk food advertising ban matters not because it will instantly solve childhood obesity. It will not. It matters because it cracks open a door that environmental policy has kept firmly shut.
For the first time in years, governments are publicly acknowledging that advertising can be harmful at scale. That it shapes norms. That it deserves regulation when public goods are at stake. Biodiversity loss and climate breakdown are public goods problems of the highest order. Yet we continue to allow their drivers to be marketed without restraint.
As the screens fill with fewer burger ads, it is worth paying attention to what remains. The fashion, the plastics, the beef, the fossil fuel branding. All still selling a version of normal that the planet cannot sustain. If advertising is powerful enough to endanger children’s health, it is powerful enough to endanger nature too. The only real question is how long we pretend otherwise.